Doyle & Doyle Jewelry Review

You would think that beautiful diamond rings would be abundant in New York...not the case if you're looking for something with character and one-of-a-kindness.  When my fiance and I started looking for rings last year, we saw a lot of generic rings that didn't speak to us.  Everyone said to try the diamond district, so we did...and realized that the same people who tell you to go there are the same people who tell you that everyone MUST visit Vegas.  It's just not true and I don't know why that myth is propelled.

I started to think that I wasn't going to fall in love with any rings and I would just have to accept that.  But one trip to Doyle and Doyle rejuvenated my faith in jewelry.  I loved their well-curated selection of estate rings (although they also have non-estate jewelry, too).  The ring we fell in love with at Doyle and Doyle is from the 1930's with deco styling.  We picked out a stone with an Old European Cut, which gave the ring further charm...perfection!

The one thing I'd disagree with other reviews here is that the employees here are friendly.  They're certainly not mean, but they're not trying to be your friend...I'd describe them all as competent, professional, informed, patient and stylish.

189 Orchard St
(between Stanton St & Houston St)
New York, NY 10002
Neighborhood: Lower East Side
(212) 677-9991

Michael F & Company Review

Looking for an engagement ring is a very big deal, and probably new territory for nearly every guy out there.  Michael F & Co. was such a wonderful find, their diamonds were absolutely gorgeous, Michael himself is there and very willing to help you, answer any questions that pop into your head, offer advice (which, for me, was correct 100% of the time) and show you a very beautiful collection of settings to go along with his gorgeous diamonds.

I compared his prices to several other jewelers in  the area, as well as many very well known online jewelers and he was consistently a bit lower than everyone else. Each time that i came to the store (which was maybe 4 times in total--two of which just to see the diamond and setting again) he was there to help me personally. When i came for the final time to pick up the ring that I had purchased, I was blown away at the final product.  It was perfect! 

Michael is very knowledgeable, and took the time to educate me on diamonds as this is the first diamond I have ever purchased.  Michael and his team were not pushy in any way, and encouraged me to do my homework and compare prices.  In the end I found that Michael had the best value for my money.  It was absolute pleasure working with Michael and I would encourage anyone looking for a diamond to reach out to Michael immediately!

7 W 47th St
(between 5th Ave & Avenue Of The Americas)
New York, NY 10036
Neighborhood: Midtown West
(212) 278-8585

David S Diamonds Review

Our initial appointment was with Stephen G.  We were lucky to be assigned to him.  His expertise and suggestions made for a great ring purchase experience.  Stephen was friendly, knowledgeable, and educated us on what we needed to know about engagement rings and wedding bands.  As a result of such guidance, we were able to purchase the correct engagement ring and wedding bands that were to our liking, satisfaction, and budget.  At no time during our visits to David S. Diamonds, did we feel pressured to purchase rings outside of our desire.

I love David. My hubby and I went the non-traditional way, where we got married first then I got my engagement ring and I picked it out. I was referred to David through my co-workers who both bought their wives engagement rings from David and because they trusted him, I knew I could too. David was the best, so patient with us, explaining everything about diamonds to us in detail and never ever pushing us to buy up or buy now. We went into David's showroom about 4 times before we decide on a diamond. For the setting, David did a custom setting that turned out beautifully and I get compliments all the time. I've already recommended several friends to David and will do so in the future. Buying an engagement ring is an overwhelming experience to begin with (even if it's my own!), to do so in a stress-free environment makes it pleasurable.

550 5th Ave
Ste 700
(between 45th St & 46th St)
New York, NY 10036
Neighborhood: Midtown West
(212) 921-8029

ID Jewelry Review

I was looking for a 5-stone ring online and found them based on price and wonderful reviews.  I purchased a 2ct, 5-stone gem lock ring from them as my wedding band in March.  It arrived as scheduled, gorgeous, great quality and the best price I could find.  The customer service and help from Yekutiel and Luann were comforting when purchasing diamonds online.

I recently visited NYC and was able to visit their store and meet everyone who worked on my ring. While there I also purchased a diamond from them for my e-ring.  Monique spent nearly 3 hours going over settings for my new diamond.  She was so very patient with me and the process.  I look forward to seeing my new setting and diamond.

I will continue to do business with them for any of my jewelry needs.  It was evident while I was there that many people trust them to pick out gifts for others, take their professional advice and were repeat customers.

8 W 47th St
Booth 49
(between 5th Ave & Avenue Of The Americas)
New York, NY 10036
Neighborhood: Midtown West
(212) 921-9372

Maurice Badler Fine Jewelry Review

Maurice Badler is the first new store to open in New York featuring famous jewelry designers in more than twenty years. We pride ourselves on our varied collections and offer a wide range of prices. There are internationally known brands featured such as Roberto Coin, Bez Ambar, Hidalgo, Gumuchian, Di Massima and SOHO, as well as extremely talented smaller designers who create fabulous pieces.

I bought my partner a pair of diamond earrings at Maurice Badler Fine Jewelry last year for an important birthday. The staff and owner (Jeff Badler) were all highly knowledgeable and saved me from buying inferior stones at a higher price!! The stones I bought from Badler Jewelers are always getting noticed, and a friend of mine who is an international diamond buyer said that they were a great deal!

Not only did I buy great diamonds, but I also got a little education from Jeff Badler the owner on diamonds and how to recognize quality. I had them appraised from an outside source and they were appraised at 30% more then I paid. I would highly recommend Badler Jewelers for any special gift big or small. I am a minority myself and found the staff very helpful and I was surprised to see the review below, I was treated with the utmost respect.

485 Park Ave
(between 58th St & 59th St)
Manhattan, NY 10022
Neighborhood: Midtown East
(800) 622-3537